Cake Bakery in McCordsville, IN - Custom Wedding or Cake Designs & Gourmet Cupcakes

Are you looking for a gorgeous cake to serve at your wedding or personalized cupcakes to pass out at a birthday party? For more than two decades now, Classic Cakes has been creating delicious custom wedding cake designs and gourmet cupcakes in the McCordsville, IN area. We will sit down with you when you visit our custom cake shop and help you figure out exactly what you want to order. Then, we will use a combination of creamy buttercream, fondant, and gum paste to make your cake or cupcakes for your next big event. We have created all kinds of beautiful cakes and cupcakes in the past and love the challenge of making your dream cake!

We Make Cakes for Any McCordsville, Indiana Celebration or Event!

  • Birthdays
  • Anniversary
  • Christenings
  • Weddings
  • Engagements
  • Baby Shower
  • Graduation
  • Baptisms
  • Confirmations
  • Gender Revealing
  • 1st Birthday
  • 21st Birthday Party
  • Bar / Bat Mitzvah
  • Meetings
  • Corporate Events
  • Social Events
  • Get Well Soon
  • And More…

Custom Wedding Cake Designer & Engagement / Anniversary Cakes

Whether you have a wedding cake design in mind or you’re still trying to figure out what you want your wedding cake to look like, a custom wedding cake designer from Classic Cakes can help bring your vision to life. Planning a wedding can be a stressful time, so we’ll do our best to make the process of creating a wedding cake as painless as possible. We can also help you put together beautiful bride and groom cakes, engagement cakes, and even anniversary cakes. We’re your one-stop shop in McCordsville, IN for custom wedding cake designs and gourmet cupcakes.

Custom Themed & Sculpted Specialty Cakes – 2D or 3D Designs

Over the years, our customers have come to Classic Cakes and asked us to make all kinds of crazy cake designs. If you have something in mind but don’t think it’s possible, we encourage you to give us a try. We have made a number of custom themed and sculpted specialty cakes and have experience with using both 2D and 3D designs. You might be pleasantly surprised by how intricate our cakes can get and what we’re actually able to do with them once we have a design in place!

Kids/Children’s Personalized Birthday Cakes

Do you want to make sure your child is smiling from ear-to-ear when you carry out their birthday cake this year? Classic Cakes guarantees your child will love the personalized birthday cake we put together for them. Whether you want a dinosaur-themed cake, a baseball cake, or a Legos, Barbie, Star Wars, or Disney cake, we can make it all. Your child will love the way it looks and the way it tastes once you cut it up and start handing it out.

McCordsville Cupcake Bakery for Weddings, Baby Showers, Birthdays & More

While many of our customers come to use for our custom cakes, we are also make and bake custom cupcakes as well. Our bakery can make cupcakes using whatever flavor you want. Cupcakes are great for weddings, birthday parties, showers, and other special events. You can pick out everything from the flavor inside of the cupcakes to the designs that are used on top of them when you call on Classic Cakes.

Below Are Our Cake & Cupcake Flavors

View Cake Flavors

Standard Flavors


Custom Flavors

Almond Pound
Chocolate Chip
Dark Raspberry
Lemon Orange Almond
Lemon Poppyseed
Mandarin Orange
Raspberry Sour Cream
Red Velvet
Chocolate Peppermint
Pink Champagne
Lemon Lavender

Deluxe Flavors

Apple Spice
Key Lime

Filling Flavors

Chocolate Truffle
Cream Cheese

Designing a custom cake or gourmet cupcakes through Classic Cakes is easy; reach out to us at 317-844-6901 today to get started.